28 August, 2026

When you're eavesdropping over breakfast at the local diner, details matter.

 Work has me on a fast path to burnout lately and I decided I would allow myself a three-day weekend to detox. My favorite way to ensure I am setting myself up for enjoying the additional free time, is to treat myself to breakfast at the local diner. This local spot is exactly the type of diner a location scout and director would determine to be quintessential small America diner from a bygone era. It's cheap, the service is great if they know you, and the conversations are not muted, restrained, or pasteurized. At a pre-dawn hour, your patrons are farmers, manufacturers, police, and linemen. 

Behind me, sat three men in their 30s, that I only identified in number and age based on their conversation and tone. At first, non-descript, discussing repairs to cars and then to one of their friends that "isn't doing so well". The unwell friend was a bridge into something that happened at a hunting/fishing(?) location that this individual and several others had camped at recently; somewhere off of Lake Marion? I presumed two things; this must be near the town of Marion, NC, but my Google Maps search this morning took me to South Carolina. Given it's distance away, I suppose there could be a lake near Marion, NC that the locals have their own name for; but alas, you read the title of this post. My other presumption, the event was recent because this group of men behind me quickly navigated their discussion towards it. Steel yourself for more ambiguities. 

For sake of this post, I am going to give the unwell friend the moniker of, James.

James and a group of friends and spouses went to a "spot" off of Lake Marion for "activity"; maybe fishing, maybe just camping and whatever came along with that. I inferred that hunting was not the intention, which will become equally clear to you, as you read along. After the party had set up their area for the "activity", one of the women in the group noticed that the water level in the lake was particularly low. The group had brought their dogs, because of course you would - you're in nature and dogs tend to enjoy being unrestrained in the wilds of the Appalachia region. I should note, if this incident did in fact occur at Lake Marion, SC; "Appalachia" would not apply here, this area would be marshy, surrounded by farmland. If however, somewhere is near Marion, NC, then, yes, we have ourselves an Appalachian Tale. In an effort to present this story in the fashion in which I overheard it, I will provide the narrative in the same cryptic way at which it entered my brain.

It was dusk, and the friends were sitting around a fire. Though not explicitly suggested, surely there were intoxicants of some nature; though not relevant to this story. One of the girls went to pee and from where she was doing her business, she could see across the lake. I can imagine the serenity of that scene; lake water gently lapping against the shore, cicada's in chorus, perhaps amphibians joining in to ensure this scene fell straight out of a 1980's camp-based horror film. She was likely scanning the landscape, maybe thinking how fortunate she is to live in such a beautiful area of the country, when at a good distance away, she saw a black figure standing at the water's edge next to the tree line. It looked big, seemed to be looking in their direction, and it creeped her out enough that she told the group when she returned. A concern that the party probably washed away and cast into the fire with all of their day to day worries. As darkness ate away at nature's light however, something, day to day survival has not prepared them for, supplants relaxation with concern.

As described in a sinister vagueness to wreck my brain, 

"...they kept coming out of the forest to the edge of where they were able to see and they were messing with the dogs." 

This line of the conversation is the point at which my brain switched from absorbing my surroundings to focusing on the story being shared behind me. Please know, my understanding of camping is what movies and books has taught me; something antagonizing dogs from a tree line in a forest on a lake, this might be a normal thing that happens?! I don't have any frame of reference for this except the impending danger my brain has been taught to be wary of. The intonation and passive way this was expressed in this morning's conversation suggested to me that either these three men knew something worse was forthcoming from this story, or that this was a "thing" that happens when you go camping with dogs. No action resulting from this event in which dogs were antagonized was shared, which my brain finds odd, so either it escalated or this was expected. What was "they"? Indeed, what was, "they"?

Fuckery continued for the party for what seemed like hours with intermittent spells of calm long enough to allow rationalization to explain away the events. Tree cracks; unusually animal sounds, sudden explosive disruptions of the lake's surface. All things that the brain is hopefully clever enough to write off; aliens camping in an alien environment. 

"It all set off. All of the animals were killed." - What?! What the hell did he just say?! 

"They had to leave them, they left everything til the next morning. They got the hell out of there. It fucked them up." - Sir, you are reinforcing every thing my stupid city-brain understands to be scared of with camping. Expressed in the same tone I ordered breakfast with. Why are you sharing this as if everyone has this kind of story to share?!

"James has video of it." - Oh?

"I only saw the first part. It had to be 8 or 9 feet." - 8 or 9 feet what?! Tall, long, wide?!

"I saw a few videos from different people. It's pretty fucked up."

"Can you send me James' video?" 

Every intrigued part of my brain was at war with every rational part of my brain. "Don't make assumptions. Don't turn around. They are not talking about this in an excited way. You are misunderstanding the context." Fuck if I didn't want to see that video though.

Waiting for blanks to be filled, I sipped my coffee. They collectively are watching the videos I presume because they have stopped talking. There's no audio I can overhear. I push the last bite of biscuits and gravy around my plate until my brain reminds me of the mashed potato scene from Close Encounters. Sip my coffee. My plate gets collected. Fuck. Nothing. The waitress arrives at their table and the inane pleasantries about so and so swallow up the mystery of the events at Lake Marion. No closure.

Individually, this is too cliche' accurate to be anything extraordinary. A figure. Noises. Dogs being dogs. Something 8 or 9 feet (long, tall, who the fuck knows). Dogs being killed by another animal. My brain wants this to be a cryptid story, and in all fairness, it can be. I don't have enough context. It's a bunch of polaroid snapshots in my brain, pieced together to come to the conclusion I want. The reality-side of my brain says a large black bear can stand in these events, check all the boxes, and most importantly, explain the placidity in which this story entered my ears.

I've not lived in Appalachia for very long. The internet would have it's residents sitting around sharing lore and folk tales about witches and cryptids like we don't have internet, and bills, and jobs, and real world problems. 99% of the conversations you can overhear in a small town diner in Appalachia is how hard things are, or genuine concern for one another, or the town, or our farmers. It's definitely not what is lurking in the woods at night. But if you decide to sit in that tiny diner following a lunar eclipse and eavesdrop just enough, you might be able to hear enough words without context to paint yourself a pretty fascinating "Appalachian Cryptid Story" to share on your blog instead of being at work.

No comments:

Post a Comment